{
 "seasonal_collections__Pearl-Flower-Bracelet--Gold.mp4": {
  "qa": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "pct": 82,
   "crit_pass": false,
   "fails": [
    "B6_captions",
    "Caption 'Love is like the...' is clipped on the right and bottom edges.",
    "Caption 'Love is like the...' is not comfortably readable at a glance due to small size and low contrast.",
    "E_locations",
    "no real environment",
    "same pose repeated"
   ],
   "checks": {
    "B1_fps": {
     "val": 24.0,
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "tech_res_dur_audio": {
     "val": {
      "res": "1080x1920",
      "dur": 14.38
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "A8_loudness": {
     "val": {
      "lufs": -14.11,
      "tp": -1.7,
      "lra": 0.9
     },
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "B_smooth_warp": {
     "val": {
      "score": 35,
      "soft": 8,
      "catastrophic": false
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Background lacks realistic texture and depth",
      "Background text and paper texture are blurry and artificial.",
      "Background text is blurry and distorted.",
      "Background text is blurry and slightly warped",
      "Fingers appear somewhat warped/lacking natural definition",
      "Garment appears melted/artificial, lacking realistic fabric details",
      "Garment has an unnatural, plastic-like texture with uniform, repetitive ridges, not resembling realistic fabric details.",
      "Garment has an unnatural, plastic-like texture, lacking realistic fabric details.",
      "Garment has morphed/melted/lost its real details (white sleeve on the left has an unnatural, plastic-like texture and rigid, unrealistic folds)",
      "Garment has morphed/melted/lost its real details (white sleeve on the left side of the frame appears unnatural and lacks realistic fabric texture)",
      "Garment texture appears artificial and lacks realistic fabric details",
      "Garment texture appears plastic-like and lacks realistic fabric details.",
      "Hand has an unnatural, smoothed, and slightly rubbery texture",
      "Hands with rubbery/fused fingers",
      "Jewelry details (gold setting) appear overly smooth and artificial",
      "Nails appear artificial",
      "Skin texture is excessively smooth, lacking natural details, giving an artificial appearance",
      "Slightly smoothed/rubbery fingers",
      "Unnatural hand shape",
      "background elements (wooden tray, white surface) appear flat and lack realistic texture/detail",
      "background text is warped/smeared",
      "charm details are blurry and lack crispness",
      "fingers appear slightly smoothed and lacking natural skin texture, giving a somewhat rubbery appearance",
      "fingers appear somewhat rubbery and lacking natural detail",
      "fingers are slightly indistinct and lack natural detail",
      "fused/rubbery fingers",
      "garment has morphed/melted/lost its real details (unnatural, plastic-like texture on sleeve)",
      "garment texture is artificial and melted/plastic-like",
      "hand appears somewhat soft and lacking realistic skin texture",
      "hands with fused/rubbery fingers",
      "index finger nail is slightly blurred",
      "lack of realistic skin texture on hand",
      "melted/smeared hand details",
      "nail on the thumb is not clearly defined",
      "rubbery fingers",
      "skin texture is overly smooth and lacks natural detail",
      "unnatural hand anatomy",
      "unnatural skin texture on hand"
     ]
    },
    "B3_anatomy": {
     "val": {
      "score": 100,
      "bad_transitions": 0
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "B4_coherence": {
     "val": {
      "score": 0,
      "per_burst": [
       15,
       0,
       10
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "frames 1-4: The entire scene, including the hand, bracelet, and background, is perfectly static across all frames. This complete absence of any natural motion or subtle variations (e.g., camera micro-movements, light fluctuations, or micro-adjustments of the hand) makes the sequence appear as a repeated still image rather than a continuous shot. This artificial stillness violates the expectation of natural motion physics and scene stability in a real video.",
      "frames 1-4: The sequence consists of identical static frames, lacking any discernible motion or change, and therefore does not read as a continuous shot of a person. This fundamental lack of temporal progression prevents evaluation of coherence.",
      "frames 1-4: The sequence consists of perfectly identical frames, which does not read as a real continuous shot. A genuine continuous video, even of a static subject, would exhibit subtle, natural variations (e.g., sensor noise, minor light shifts, imperceptible micro-movements) over a 1.2-second duration."
     ]
    },
    "B5_reality": {
     "val": {
      "score": 20,
      "per_burst": [
       100,
       20,
       30
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "The arm and bracelet are perfectly static across all frames, lacking any natural micro-movements expected from a living subject over ~1.2 seconds. This unnatural stillness suggests a frozen frame or AI generation.",
      "The complete lack of any movement or subtle variation across all four consecutive frames (1-4) is unnatural for a continuous shot from a real-world video, suggesting a static image or freeze-frame.",
      "The video appears completely frozen across all four frames, with no discernible movement or change in the arm, bracelet, clothing, or background elements, which is unnatural for a continuous shot from a fashion video."
     ]
    },
    "B6_captions": {
     "val": {
      "score": 0,
      "per_frame": [
       100,
       0,
       100
      ]
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "Caption 'Love is like the...' is clipped on the right and bottom edges.",
      "Caption 'Love is like the...' is not comfortably readable at a glance due to small size and low contrast."
     ],
     "crit": true
    },
    "B7_formats": {
     "val": {
      "feed45": "seasonal_collections__Pearl-Flower-Bracelet--Gold_45.mp4"
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "D_brand_claim": {
     "val": 100,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "E_locations": {
     "val": 10,
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "no real environment",
      "same pose repeated"
     ],
     "crit": true
    }
   }
  },
  "owner_lens": {
   "flags": [
    {
     "issue": "All scenes feature the same background, violating the rule of distinct backdrops. This makes the video feel repetitive and lacks the premium variety expected.",
     "severity": "blocker",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "All frames"
    },
    {
     "issue": "The same hand-holding pose is repeated across multiple frames (1, 2, 4, 5), making the video static and boring, which is a direct violation of the 'different pose/movement' rule.",
     "severity": "blocker",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "Frames 1, 2, 4, 5"
    },
    {
     "issue": "The video claims to showcase '3 looks' but only presents the bracelet in a single, repetitive setting. It fails to deliver on the promise of demonstrating actual styled looks or different contexts.",
     "severity": "minor",
     "votes": 1,
     "where": "Overall video concept vs. visual execution"
    }
   ],
   "would_run": false,
   "would_run_votes": 0,
   "score": 25.0,
   "judges": [
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 35
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 25
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 15
    }
   ]
  },
  "audio": {
   "ok": true,
   "fade_db": 3.0,
   "last_db": -15.2,
   "prev_db": -12.2,
   "note": "music fades cleanly at the end, VO not cut"
  },
  "crew_verdict": "FAIL"
 }
}