{
 "new_arrivals__Pearl-Flower-Bracelet--Gold.mp4": {
  "qa": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "pct": 82,
   "crit_pass": false,
   "fails": [
    "B6_captions",
    "Caption text 'VERY BESTY' is too small to be comfortably readable at a glance.",
    "E_locations",
    "no real environment",
    "same pose repeated"
   ],
   "checks": {
    "B1_fps": {
     "val": 24.0,
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "tech_res_dur_audio": {
     "val": {
      "res": "1080x1920",
      "dur": 17.88
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "A8_loudness": {
     "val": {
      "lufs": -14.62,
      "tp": -1.94,
      "lra": 1.2
     },
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "B_smooth_warp": {
     "val": {
      "score": 35,
      "soft": 7,
      "catastrophic": false
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Background surface unnaturally smooth",
      "Background warping/lacking realistic details; the white plate and surface folds appear overly smooth and somewhat artificial",
      "Bracelet charm/clasp is blurry and indistinct, losing its real details",
      "Fingernails have an unnatural shape and texture",
      "Fingers appear slightly rubbery and overly smooth",
      "Fingers lack definition, especially knuckles and nails",
      "Garment appears artificial/morphed",
      "Garment appears smoothed and lacks realistic fabric details",
      "Garment has morphed/lost its real details; fabric folds appear artificial and lack realistic depth",
      "Hand appears rubbery and lacks realistic skin texture",
      "Hand has fused and rubbery fingers",
      "Rubbery/fused fingers",
      "Skin texture on the hands lacks natural detail, appearing somewhat melted in areas",
      "Stretched/melted skin on arm due to overly smooth, plastic-like texture",
      "Unnatural and plastic-like skin texture on the hand",
      "Unnatural skin texture on hand",
      "Unnaturally smooth skin texture on arm/wrist",
      "Unrealistic skin texture on arm",
      "Unrealistic, overly smooth skin texture lacking natural details",
      "blurry and undefined fingernails",
      "fingernails lack natural detail",
      "fingers appear rubbery and slightly fused",
      "fingers appear slightly rubbery and lack natural skin texture",
      "fingers appear slightly rubbery and smoothed",
      "fused fingers",
      "garment fabric appears simplified and lacks realistic texture",
      "hands with fused/rubbery fingers (unnatural skin texture and smoothness)",
      "lack of natural skin texture and detail on hands",
      "rubbery fingers",
      "softened and smeared hand texture",
      "unnatural skin texture on hands",
      "unrealistic skin texture (overly smooth/plastic-like)"
     ]
    },
    "B3_anatomy": {
     "val": {
      "score": 20,
      "bad_transitions": 1
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Subtle morphing/warping of garment fabric: The folds and texture of the white shirt show minor, unmotivated changes between frames, particularly a softening and rearrangement of wrinkles, without a clear corresponding body movement to justify the alteration in fabric drape. This subtle inconsistency contributes to an artificial appearance.",
      "The garment's fabric texture and folds morph unnaturally between frames, appearing significantly smoothed out and less defined in the second image.",
      "The logo on the garment blurs and loses definition between frames, indicating warping or an unnatural transition."
     ]
    },
    "B4_coherence": {
     "val": {
      "score": 0,
      "per_burst": [
       95,
       0,
       95
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "frames 1-4: No person is present in the frames, a fundamental requirement for the evaluation.",
      "frames 1-4: The sequence exhibits no temporal progression or motion, consisting of identical static frames, thus failing to represent a continuous shot."
     ]
    },
    "B5_reality": {
     "val": {
      "score": 10,
      "per_burst": [
       10,
       100,
       100
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "The hand holding the bracelet and the bracelet itself exhibit no natural micro-movements across frames 1-4, making the scene appear completely static like a still image rather than a continuous video shot."
     ]
    },
    "B6_captions": {
     "val": {
      "score": 30,
      "per_frame": [
       100,
       100,
       100,
       30
      ]
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "Caption text 'VERY BESTY' is too small to be comfortably readable at a glance."
     ],
     "crit": true
    },
    "B7_formats": {
     "val": {
      "feed45": "new_arrivals__Pearl-Flower-Bracelet--Gold_45.mp4"
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "D_brand_claim": {
     "val": 100,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "E_locations": {
     "val": 20,
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "no real environment",
      "same pose repeated"
     ],
     "crit": true
    }
   }
  },
  "owner_lens": {
   "flags": [
    {
     "issue": "Every scene must have a distinct, realistic background. The same background is used for all five frames, which is repetitive and violates the 'never the same backdrop twice' rule.",
     "severity": "blocker",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "Frames 1-5"
    },
    {
     "issue": "Every beat must show a different pose/movement. Frame 4 is nearly identical to Frame 1, and Frame 5 is nearly identical to Frame 2, making the presentation boring and repetitive.",
     "severity": "minor",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "Frames 1, 2, 4, 5"
    },
    {
     "issue": "The focus shifts abruptly in Frame 3 to a clothing shot without the product, which breaks the flow and makes the video less cohesive for a jewelry ad.",
     "severity": "minor",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "Frame 3"
    },
    {
     "issue": "The text 'Sized S to 3X' is confusing and irrelevant when the primary product being advertised is a bracelet, not clothing. This detracts from the premium feel.",
     "severity": "minor",
     "votes": 1,
     "where": "Frame 5"
    }
   ],
   "would_run": false,
   "would_run_votes": 0,
   "score": 23.3,
   "judges": [
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 25
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 25
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 20
    }
   ]
  },
  "audio": {
   "ok": false,
   "fade_db": null,
   "note": "could not measure audio (no track?)"
  },
  "crew_verdict": "FAIL"
 }
}