{
 "seasonal_collections__Summer-Edit-0724.mp4": {
  "qa": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "pct": 91,
   "crit_pass": false,
   "fails": [
    "B4_coherence",
    "frames 2-3: Facial expression abruptly shifts from a wide smile to a more neutral look, lacking a smooth transition."
   ],
   "checks": {
    "B1_fps": {
     "val": 24.0,
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "tech_res_dur_audio": {
     "val": {
      "res": "1080x1920",
      "dur": 14.38
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "A8_loudness": {
     "val": {
      "lufs": -14.66,
      "tp": -1.89,
      "lra": 1.9
     },
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "B_smooth_warp": {
     "val": {
      "score": 35,
      "soft": 5,
      "catastrophic": false
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Artificial hair texture: The hair has an unnatural, plastic-like texture, particularly visible in its smoothness and lack of realistic strand definition.",
      "Artificial-looking hair texture",
      "Face appears overly smoothed and lacks realistic skin texture, giving a smeared/unnatural appearance.",
      "Face has an artificial, plastic-like appearance with subtle asymmetry",
      "Footwear (slides) appear blobby/morphed, and toes are fused.",
      "Garment fabric texture and drape look stiff and unnatural",
      "Garment texture appears somewhat uniform and artificial",
      "Garment texture on top and pants appears morphed/melted and lacks realistic detail.",
      "Garment: The texture and edges of the pink top appear somewhat melted and lack realistic fabric definition, especially at the bottom hem and sleeves.",
      "Left hand fingers appear somewhat fused and unnatural",
      "Melted/smeared face: The nose bridge and nostrils appear smoothed and lack natural definition, and the overall skin texture is overly smooth.",
      "Melted/smoothed facial features: The face appears overly smooth and somewhat artificial, lacking natural skin texture.",
      "Overly smoothed face lacking natural skin texture",
      "Right foot and slide appear slightly unnatural, possibly with fused toes",
      "Right hand has fused/rubber fingers.",
      "Rubbery/fused fingers: The fingers on the left hand holding the hat appear thick and somewhat rubbery, lacking natural articulation.",
      "garment that has morphed/melted/lost its real details",
      "hands with fused/rubber fingers",
      "soft/indistinct right hand"
     ]
    },
    "B3_anatomy": {
     "val": {
      "score": 40,
      "bad_transitions": 1
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "The texture and pattern of the pink top subtly morph and warp between frames, particularly noticeable on the back of the garment."
     ]
    },
    "B4_coherence": {
     "val": {
      "score": 10,
      "per_burst": [
       35,
       10,
       35
      ]
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "frames 2-3: Facial expression abruptly shifts from a wide smile to a more neutral look, lacking a smooth transition."
     ],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Garment Lock (frames 1-4): The floral pattern on the top subtly shifts, warps, and repositions itself across frames, and the garment's overall fit subtly changes, demonstrating a lack of consistent garment texture and form.",
      "Identity Lock (frames 1-4): The model's face subtly morphs across frames, with changes in facial structure, eye shape, and smile that do not represent natural expression changes but rather a regeneration of facial features.",
      "Limb Continuity / Body Proportions (frames 1-4): The model's body width and limb positions subtly shift and warp between frames, particularly the left arm (viewer's right) and the overall torso, indicating a lack of consistent 3D form.",
      "frames 1-3: The feet exhibit unnatural and jerky movement. The right foot is forward in frame 1, the left foot is forward in frame 2, and then the right foot is forward again in frame 3, indicating a rapid and implausible 'pop' in stance for a continuous motion.",
      "frames 1-4: MOTION PHYSICS: The fabric of the top exhibits no natural drape or subtle movement consistent with the slight body shifts between frames.",
      "frames 1-4: MOTION PHYSICS: The model's hair remains completely static and frozen across all frames, showing no natural movement despite the subtle shifts in body position and leg movement.",
      "frames 1-4: No discernible movement or temporal progression across frames; the sequence appears to be a repeated still image rather than a continuous shot, failing to demonstrate natural motion physics or any dynamic element.",
      "frames 1-4: The hair appears somewhat static or unnaturally changes shape/position without corresponding body movement, indicating a motion physics flaw.",
      "frames 1-4: The model's facial features, particularly the smile and eye shape, subtly shift and morph across frames, indicating an identity lock issue typical of AI generation.",
      "frames 1-4: The sequence consists of four identical still images, showing no temporal progression or movement. This does not constitute a continuous shot of a real person, as expected for temporal coherence evaluation.",
      "frames 1-4: The subject, her hair, and clothing are unnaturally frozen across all frames. There is no subtle movement expected from a real person over 1.2 seconds (0.4s x 3 intervals), making the sequence appear as identical still images rather than a continuous shot. This violates motion physics and the expectation of a real continuous shot.",
      "frames 2-4: Subtle, non-fluid changes in the volume and shape of the model's hair on the left side (viewer's right), lacking natural motion physics.",
      "frames 2-4: Subtle, non-fluid shifts in the position of the model's left arm (viewer's right), indicating minor limb popping rather than continuous movement."
     ]
    },
    "B5_reality": {
     "val": {
      "score": 85,
      "per_burst": [
       85,
       100,
       100
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "The right curtain tie-back shifts position and tautness between frame 1 and frame 2, remaining in the new position for subsequent frames. This is an inconsistency in a static background element."
     ]
    },
    "B6_captions": {
     "val": {
      "score": 100,
      "per_frame": [
       100,
       100,
       100
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "B7_formats": {
     "val": {
      "feed45": "seasonal_collections__Summer-Edit-0724_45.mp4"
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "D_brand_claim": {
     "val": 100,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "E_locations": {
     "val": 90,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    }
   }
  },
  "owner_lens": {
   "flags": [
    {
     "issue": "The background is repeated across consecutive frames, violating the distinct background rule.",
     "severity": "minor",
     "votes": 2,
     "where": "Frames 1, 2, 4, and 5"
    },
    {
     "issue": "Model repeats the same pose across two beats, which is boring and not distinct movement.",
     "severity": "minor",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "Frames 4 and 5"
    }
   ],
   "would_run": false,
   "would_run_votes": 1,
   "score": 64.3,
   "judges": [
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 65
    },
    {
     "would_run": true,
     "score": 88
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 40
    }
   ]
  },
  "crew_verdict": "FAIL"
 }
}