{
 "FINALIST_kling.mp4": {
  "qa": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "pct": 82,
   "crit_pass": false,
   "fails": [
    "B3_anatomy",
    "B4_coherence",
    "Subtle facial morphing/warping, particularly around the jawline and mouth, which subtly changes shape between frames.",
    "frames 1-3: Head-body coupling: The head rotates significantly to the left across these frames, while the torso remains largely static, creating an unnatural and disconnected movement.",
    "frames 1-4: Identity lock: The woman's face morphs significantly across all frames, particularly noticeable in the jawline, chin, and eye shape, making her appear as a different person in subsequent frames.",
    "frames 2-3: The drape and folds of the dress fabric on the lap and around the left leg (viewer's right) change abruptly and unnaturally, revealing more leg in frame 3.",
    "frames 3-4: Abrupt change in body posture from a crouched position to a more upright stance, feeling like a jump cut rather than a smooth, continuous motion.",
    "frames 3-4: Garment pattern and drape on the skirt change drastically and unnaturally; patterns warp, shift, and re-materialize, and the overall fit and waistline appear different.",
    "frames 3-4: The arm positions abruptly change, particularly the right arm moving from being down and slightly back to bent and lifted forward, and the left arm lifting to hold the dress. This creates a 'pop' rather than a smooth, continuous motion, breaking limb continuity.",
    "frames 3-4: The body posture shifts significantly from seated to a more upright/leaning position, but the dress fabric on the lap completely flattens and changes its folds and pattern alignment in an abrupt, non-physical manner. The left leg (viewer's right) goes from partially exposed to almost entirely covered by the dress in a single jump.",
    "frames 3-4: The head's relatively minor adjustment does not fully align with the significant shift in the body's posture, indicating poor head-body coupling."
   ],
   "checks": {
    "B1_fps": {
     "val": 24.0,
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "tech_res_dur_audio": {
     "val": {
      "res": "1080x1920",
      "dur": 12.88
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "A8_loudness": {
     "val": {
      "lufs": -14.82,
      "tp": -1.81,
      "lra": 1.9
     },
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "B_smooth_warp": {
     "val": {
      "score": 30,
      "soft": 7,
      "catastrophic": true
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Artificial and flat texture of the sand/ground in the foreground",
      "Background and steps are overly soft and lack realistic detail, contributing to an artificial look",
      "Background appears overly smoothed and lacks natural texture, contributing to an artificial overall look.",
      "Background elements (sand, stairs) show slight artificiality/blurring",
      "Background elements (stairs and sand) have an artificial/painted appearance.",
      "Background stairs show minor warping and softness.",
      "Dress patterns are inconsistent and show minor warping",
      "Face is slightly blurred and lacks realistic detail, giving a generic AI appearance",
      "Fingers appear thick and rubbery, lacking realistic definition.",
      "Fingers on both hands appear rubbery and somewhat fused",
      "Fused and rubbery fingers on the left hand",
      "Garment (dress) has morphed/melted/lost its real details; the pattern appears artificial and smeared.",
      "Garment appears melted/smeared/distorted, losing realistic fabric details",
      "Garment details appear slightly morphed/softened in areas",
      "Garment details appear soft and slightly morphed in some areas",
      "Garment fabric lacks realistic flow and texture, appearing somewhat painted",
      "Garment fabric texture appears flat and somewhat melted",
      "Garment pattern appears melted/smeared and lacks realistic fabric details",
      "Garment pattern appears morphed/lacks realistic detail",
      "Garment pattern appears smeared and lacks realistic fabric details in several areas",
      "Garment pattern appears somewhat painted-on and lacks natural fabric texture and flow",
      "Garment pattern details appear somewhat inconsistent and painted on, lacking realistic fabric texture in areas.",
      "Garment pattern is morphed, inconsistent, and lacks realistic detail",
      "Garment pattern shows distortion and loss of realistic fabric details, especially on the sleeves, waist, and lower part of the dress, appearing somewhat melted or painted.",
      "Garment pattern shows signs of melting and abstraction, lacking realistic fabric details in several areas.",
      "Garment: The dress pattern is highly repetitive and lacks realistic fabric texture, appearing artificial and melted in details.",
      "Ground texture and rock in the foreground appear artificial",
      "Hair has an artificial texture.",
      "Hands appear rubbery and smoothed, with artificial-looking nails on both hands.",
      "Hands appear slightly unnatural and rubbery, with some fingers looking thick or stubby.",
      "Hands are soft and lack definition, particularly around the fingers and wrists",
      "Hands with fused/rubbery fingers",
      "Hands: Fingers on the visible right hand appear fused and rubbery.",
      "Hat has an artificial, melted texture.",
      "Hat texture is somewhat melted and lacks realistic detail",
      "Hat texture lacks realism/detail",
      "Melted and smoothed facial features, particularly around the jawline and cheek, lacking natural skin texture.",
      "Melted/soft/warped facial features (jawline, nose, lips)",
      "Overall realism: The textures of the hair, skin, and sand appear overly smooth and artificial, lacking natural detail.",
      "Right hand (model's right) fingers appear soft and somewhat fused",
      "Right hand fingers appear fused and rubber-like",
      "Rings on the right hand appear partially merged with the fingers.",
      "Rings on the right hand are distorted and unnatural",
      "Rubbery/fused fingers on both hands with unnatural shapes",
      "Sand texture appears somewhat artificial.",
      "Skin texture on arms is overly smooth, contributing to an artificial appearance.",
      "Slightly melted/smeared face on the left side",
      "Slightly unrealistic facial features, appearing too smooth and soft",
      "The visible hand (model's left) shows fused/rubbery fingers.",
      "distorted left ankle/foot",
      "fused and rubbery fingers on both hands",
      "garment pattern appears melted/lacks realistic detail",
      "garment pattern appears morphed and lacks realistic fabric details",
      "melted/smoothed face",
      "rubbery/fused fingers on right hand"
     ]
    },
    "B3_anatomy": {
     "val": {
      "score": 20,
      "bad_transitions": 1
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "Subtle facial morphing/warping, particularly around the jawline and mouth, which subtly changes shape between frames."
     ],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Garment folds and hair are unnaturally static between frames, indicating no natural movement of dynamic elements."
     ]
    },
    "B4_coherence": {
     "val": {
      "score": 20,
      "per_burst": [
       40,
       35,
       20
      ]
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "frames 1-3: Head-body coupling: The head rotates significantly to the left across these frames, while the torso remains largely static, creating an unnatural and disconnected movement.",
      "frames 1-4: Identity lock: The woman's face morphs significantly across all frames, particularly noticeable in the jawline, chin, and eye shape, making her appear as a different person in subsequent frames.",
      "frames 2-3: The drape and folds of the dress fabric on the lap and around the left leg (viewer's right) change abruptly and unnaturally, revealing more leg in frame 3.",
      "frames 3-4: Abrupt change in body posture from a crouched position to a more upright stance, feeling like a jump cut rather than a smooth, continuous motion.",
      "frames 3-4: Garment pattern and drape on the skirt change drastically and unnaturally; patterns warp, shift, and re-materialize, and the overall fit and waistline appear different.",
      "frames 3-4: The arm positions abruptly change, particularly the right arm moving from being down and slightly back to bent and lifted forward, and the left arm lifting to hold the dress. This creates a 'pop' rather than a smooth, continuous motion, breaking limb continuity.",
      "frames 3-4: The body posture shifts significantly from seated to a more upright/leaning position, but the dress fabric on the lap completely flattens and changes its folds and pattern alignment in an abrupt, non-physical manner. The left leg (viewer's right) goes from partially exposed to almost entirely covered by the dress in a single jump.",
      "frames 3-4: The head's relatively minor adjustment does not fully align with the significant shift in the body's posture, indicating poor head-body coupling."
     ],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "frames 1-4: Subtle warping and instability are present in the background steps and the pillar on the left.",
      "frames 1-4: The arm movements appear stiff and somewhat disconnected, transitioning between distinct poses rather than exhibiting continuous, fluid motion.",
      "frames 1-4: The fabric of the dress, particularly the lower section, exhibits inconsistent drape and pattern alignment, suggesting warping or a lack of realistic motion physics.",
      "frames 1-4: The hair appears unnaturally stiff and shows minimal, unrealistic movement despite subtle shifts in the model's head and body.",
      "frames 1-4: The model's hair remains largely static throughout the sequence, failing to respond naturally to the implied body movement.",
      "frames 2-3: Limb continuity is broken; the left leg, which was lifting in frame 2, is suddenly planted on the ground in frame 3, while the right leg moves from a forward position to a backward position. This creates a noticeable jump in the walking motion.",
      "frames 2-3: Motion physics are inconsistent; the flowing fabric on the right side of the dress in frame 2 abruptly settles and changes shape in frame 3, which is not consistent with continuous movement.",
      "frames 2-3: The dress fabric on the model's left side (viewer's right) abruptly pulls back in after flowing out in frame 2, creating a noticeable pop in its movement.",
      "frames 3-4: Garment lock: The dress appears to pull up, revealing more leg, and the neckline deepens, indicating an inconsistent fit or length of the garment between frames.",
      "frames 3-4: Limb continuity is broken as the right leg (viewer's left) and arms adjust unnaturally and abruptly to the sudden change in body posture.",
      "frames 3-4: Motion physics are violated as the fabric re-drapes implausibly and the hair remains relatively static despite the significant body movement.",
      "frames 3-4: The dress fabric on the model's left side (viewer's right) suddenly flows out significantly, lacking a smooth transition from the previous frame's more contained state."
     ]
    },
    "B5_reality": {
     "val": {
      "score": 25,
      "per_burst": [
       50,
       100,
       25
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "The intricate pattern and fabric folds of the dress visibly warp and rebuild across all frames. Specific blue motifs and borders on the bodice, sleeves, and skirt change in design and placement from frame to frame, which is not consistent with a real garment (Frames 1-4).",
      "The model's right hand exhibits an unnatural and discontinuous movement across frames. It is holding the dress in frame 1, then drops to her side in frames 2 and 3, only to abruptly return to holding the dress again in frame 4. This rapid and non-fluid change in action would be noticeable to an ordinary viewer.",
      "The pattern on the dress skirt warps and shifts inconsistently between frames, particularly noticeable on the lower left side of the skirt across frames 1-4."
     ]
    },
    "B6_captions": {
     "val": {
      "score": 100,
      "per_frame": [
       100,
       100,
       100
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "B7_formats": {
     "val": {
      "feed45": "FINALIST_kling_45.mp4"
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "D_brand_claim": {
     "val": 100,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "E_locations": {
     "val": 90,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    }
   }
  },
  "owner_lens": {
   "flags": [
    {
     "issue": "Lack of distinct backgrounds. All scenes use the exact same backdrop, violating the rule that every scene must have a distinct background. This makes the video appear cheap and unvaried.",
     "severity": "blocker",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "All frames"
    },
    {
     "issue": "Repetitive pose between frames 4 and 5. The sitting position and hand placement are nearly identical, with only a slight head turn and camera angle change.",
     "severity": "minor",
     "votes": 2,
     "where": "Frames 4 and 5"
    }
   ],
   "would_run": false,
   "would_run_votes": 0,
   "score": 35.0,
   "judges": [
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 35
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 35
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 35
    }
   ]
  },
  "crew_verdict": "FAIL"
 },
 "FINALIST_runway.mp4": {
  "qa": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "pct": 64,
   "crit_pass": false,
   "fails": [
    "B3_anatomy",
    "B4_coherence",
    "B5_reality",
    "B_smooth_warp",
    "Feet appear soft and blurry, lacking realistic anatomical detail. The model is barefoot or wearing extremely sheer hosiery in a shoes-expected setting.",
    "Footwear: The model is barefoot in a shoes-expected setting (concrete stairs), and the feet appear somewhat rubbery and unnatural.",
    "Garment morphing/warping: The dress fabric around the left leg significantly changes shape and volume between frames, appearing to billow out and stretch in an unnatural manner, rather than simply flowing with movement.",
    "Model is barefoot in a shoes-expected setting (stone steps)",
    "The 'VK VERKRAFTY' logo in the top right corner jitters slightly in position between frames 1, 2, and 3. Between frames 3 and 4, it shifts significantly to the right and slightly up, and its color changes from black and white to black and red.",
    "frames 1-4: Head remains rigidly camera-locked while the body moves forward and shifts weight, creating an unnatural, floating head effect."
   ],
   "checks": {
    "B1_fps": {
     "val": 24.0,
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "tech_res_dur_audio": {
     "val": {
      "res": "1080x1920",
      "dur": 12.88
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "A8_loudness": {
     "val": {
      "lufs": -14.88,
      "tp": -1.95,
      "lra": 1.0
     },
     "pass": true,
     "crit": true
    },
    "B_smooth_warp": {
     "val": {
      "score": 15,
      "soft": 8,
      "catastrophic": true
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "Feet appear soft and blurry, lacking realistic anatomical detail. The model is barefoot or wearing extremely sheer hosiery in a shoes-expected setting.",
      "Footwear: The model is barefoot in a shoes-expected setting (concrete stairs), and the feet appear somewhat rubbery and unnatural.",
      "Model is barefoot in a shoes-expected setting (stone steps)"
     ],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Artificial ground texture",
      "Artificial skin texture on face",
      "Artificial texture of the dress fabric.",
      "Background shows minor warping/lack of detail",
      "Background stairs exhibit warping and inconsistent lines",
      "Background steps and wall show artificiality and minor warping",
      "Background structures appear overly smooth and artificial, lacking realistic texture",
      "Background wall texture is overly smooth and artificial",
      "Background warping",
      "Background warping is present on the stairs and pillar, which lack realistic texture and definition.",
      "Belt knot appears flat and lacks realistic folds",
      "Bracelet on left wrist appears chunky/fused",
      "Distorted and melted wrist bracelets",
      "Distorted and repetitive patterns on dress",
      "Dress fabric texture and pattern appear flat and painted, lacking realistic detail",
      "Dress pattern is highly repetitive and lacks realistic fabric details, appearing painted on",
      "Face profile appears soft and melted, blending unnaturally with hair",
      "Feet appear simplified and somewhat unnatural",
      "Feet/footwear appear rubbery and lack definition",
      "Fingers on the left hand appear rubbery and partially fused",
      "Fingers on the left hand are slightly indistinct and rubbery, and the bracelet texture is fused",
      "Fingers on the right hand appear rubbery and somewhat fused",
      "Fused and blurry left wrist/bracelet",
      "Fused and rubbery fingers on both hands",
      "Fused and rubbery fingers on the left hand",
      "Garment details appear morphed and melted, not resembling realistic fabric texture.",
      "Garment details are morphed/melted/smeared and lack realistic fabric texture",
      "Garment fabric texture lacks realistic details and folds",
      "Garment has morphed/melted/lost its real details",
      "Garment has morphed/melted/lost its real details (pattern is smeared and warped)",
      "Garment has morphed/melted/lost its real details, with an abstract and smeared pattern lacking realistic fabric texture.",
      "Garment pattern appears inconsistent and lacks realistic fabric details",
      "Garment pattern appears melted and lacks crisp detail",
      "Garment pattern appears melted and lacks realistic detail",
      "Garment pattern appears melted and lacks realistic fabric details",
      "Garment pattern appears melted and smeared, lacking realistic fabric texture and detail",
      "Garment pattern appears melted, smeared, and morphed, lacking realistic fabric details",
      "Garment pattern appears morphed and lacks realistic fabric texture, particularly the intricate blue and gold designs",
      "Garment pattern appears noisy and melted in areas",
      "Garment pattern is melted and smeared, lacking realistic detail",
      "Ground texture lacks realism",
      "Hand fingers appear fused and lack realistic definition.",
      "Hands have fused and rubbery fingers",
      "Hands with fused/rubber fingers",
      "Left hand fingers appear rubbery and indistinct",
      "Melted and smeared patterns on the dress, lacking realistic detail and crispness.",
      "Melted appearance of bracelets",
      "Melted/distorted watch",
      "Melted/smoothed face texture",
      "Melted/unnatural appearance of dress hem",
      "Right hand fingers appear fused and simplified",
      "Right hand fingers look rubbery and fused",
      "Rubbery and fused fingers on the left hand",
      "Rubbery and fused fingers on the visible left hand, lacking natural definition.",
      "Rubbery/unrealistic arm",
      "Rubbery/unrealistic feet",
      "Sand texture appears artificial",
      "Sand texture at the bottom appears artificial",
      "Slight facial asymmetry",
      "Slight warping and smoothing in background elements, such as the steps and ground texture",
      "Slightly artificial facial texture",
      "Smoothed and artificial appearance of visible legs and feet",
      "The watch on the right wrist appears distorted and melted.",
      "Tie-belt on the dress lacks realistic fabric texture and appears somewhat fused",
      "Unnatural fabric texture on dress",
      "Unnatural smoothness and lack of fine detail in the face, with slightly 'painted' looking teeth",
      "Warped and asymmetric facial features, particularly around the jawline and chin.",
      "background (stairs and sand) has a somewhat warped/unrealistic texture",
      "background pillar and wall exhibit unnatural smoothness and lack realistic texture",
      "background stairs show warping and inconsistencies",
      "fingers on right hand appear fused and rubbery",
      "fused/rubber fingers on left hand",
      "fused/rubbery fingers on the right hand",
      "fused/rubbery fingers on the visible hand",
      "garment (dress) appears morphed and lacks realistic fabric details",
      "garment flow appears artificial",
      "garment has lost real details and texture, especially in the flowing skirt",
      "garment has melted and abstract patterns, losing real details",
      "garment pattern appears melted/painted and lacks realistic fabric details, especially where the fabric is lifted",
      "garment pattern appears morphed and lacks realistic details",
      "garment patterns appear inconsistent and blurry in areas",
      "garment that has morphed/lost its real details",
      "hair appears painted and lacks fine detail",
      "hand with fused/rubbery fingers",
      "melted/smoothed face features (jawline and neck area)",
      "melted/smoothed profile of the face and neck area",
      "skin texture on face and arm looks artificial",
      "unnatural smoothing of skin on limbs"
     ]
    },
    "B3_anatomy": {
     "val": {
      "score": 35,
      "bad_transitions": 1
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "Garment morphing/warping: The dress fabric around the left leg significantly changes shape and volume between frames, appearing to billow out and stretch in an unnatural manner, rather than simply flowing with movement."
     ],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": []
    },
    "B4_coherence": {
     "val": {
      "score": 25,
      "per_burst": [
       35,
       95,
       25
      ]
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "frames 1-4: Head remains rigidly camera-locked while the body moves forward and shifts weight, creating an unnatural, floating head effect."
     ],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "Motion Physics / Garment Lock: The draping and folds of the dress, particularly on the left side of the skirt, are highly inconsistent and appear to re-render or reset between frames (e.g., frames 1-2, 2-3, 3-4). The fabric does not maintain continuous form or flow naturally with the subtle body movements.",
      "frames 1-4: Hair remains unnaturally static despite the body's movement, lacking natural sway.",
      "frames 3-4: The arm movements, particularly the right arm swinging back and the left arm swinging forward, appear abrupt and less fluid than natural human motion, suggesting a 'snap' rather than a smooth transition in the walking cycle."
     ]
    },
    "B5_reality": {
     "val": {
      "score": 35,
      "per_burst": [
       100,
       35,
       60
      ]
     },
     "pass": false,
     "defects": [
      "The 'VK VERKRAFTY' logo in the top right corner jitters slightly in position between frames 1, 2, and 3. Between frames 3 and 4, it shifts significantly to the right and slightly up, and its color changes from black and white to black and red."
     ],
     "crit": true,
     "cosmetic": [
      "The bracelet on the left wrist changes between frame 3 and frame 4. It appears to be a silver, multi-strand bracelet in frames 1-3, but changes to a darker, single-band item (possibly a watch or different bracelet) in frame 4.",
      "The bracelet on the woman's left wrist changes from a metallic, multi-strand design in frames 1-3 to a wider, brown band in frame 4.",
      "The wrist accessory on the woman's right arm changes from a metallic bracelet in frame 3 to a brown strap watch in frame 4."
     ]
    },
    "B6_captions": {
     "val": {
      "score": 100,
      "per_frame": [
       100,
       100,
       100
      ]
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "B7_formats": {
     "val": {
      "feed45": "FINALIST_runway_45.mp4"
     },
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "D_brand_claim": {
     "val": 100,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    },
    "E_locations": {
     "val": 90,
     "pass": true,
     "defects": [],
     "crit": true
    }
   }
  },
  "owner_lens": {
   "flags": [
    {
     "issue": "Every scene must have a distinct, realistic background. This video uses the exact same backdrop (white stairs and column) for all frames, which makes it look cheap and uninspired, not premium.",
     "severity": "blocker",
     "votes": 3,
     "where": "All frames"
    }
   ],
   "would_run": false,
   "would_run_votes": 0,
   "score": 31.7,
   "judges": [
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 35
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 35
    },
    {
     "would_run": false,
     "score": 25
    }
   ]
  },
  "crew_verdict": "FAIL"
 }
}